The Church’s Ghost Stories
The Mystery of The Invisible DogMrs O’Reilly’s belief in a dead pastor, the neighborhood’s folklore, and the boys’ encounter leave the church’s haunting uncertain even after the burglary is explained.
increasing
Bearing strength in each event
decreasing
A Housekeeper’s Claim

A Housekeeper’s Claim
A local ghost
Mrs O’Reilly says that she has seen the former pastor walking with a candle. Father McGovern rejects the story, while neighbors treat it as familiar gossip.
Folklore in the background
The tale makes a supernatural explanation available before the boys encounter anything themselves. It also shapes how witnesses interpret ambiguous sights.
A Cultural Source

A Cultural Source
Childhood stories revisited
Professor Eugenia Lantine learns that Mrs O’Reilly grew up near a church said to be haunted by a priest lost at sea. The childhood legend resembles the local apparition.
A plausible construction
Lantine suspects that Mrs O’Reilly unconsciously rebuilt the familiar figure from old stories. Her theory explains a report without proving that every sighting is imaginary.
The Candle in the Dark

The Candle in the Dark
An apparent apparition
Jupiter Jones enters the church and sees a white-haired figure in dark clerical clothes holding a candle. The man snuffs it out and disappears from sight.
Fear becomes physical
Jupiter is shoved and locked inside. Whatever the candle-bearer was, another person’s attack proves that the church’s mystery includes real danger.
A Missing Saint

A Missing Saint
A remembered statue
Jupiter Jones says a statue of Saint Patrick was present the previous night, but Father McGovern says no such permanent statue belongs there. The costume pieces had been used in a pageant.
A thief’s disguise
The explanation supports Jupiter’s theory that the burglar posed as a statue. It resolves the church search while leaving the candle-bearing figure unexplained.
The Final Possibility

The Final Possibility
Explanations compared
Jupiter Jones considers Elmquist’s wandering form, a physical disguise, and a genuine phantom. Each explanation accounts for some details but fails to account for others.
Uncertainty retained
The boys do not claim that a ghost has been proved. Their refusal to force a conclusion preserves the church’s haunting as an open question.
The first night of the police search
During Bob Andrews’s university visit
Around midnight during the overnight watch
Immediately after Jupiter is released
Mid-January during the account to Alfred Hitchcock